Variation and adaptation, natural selection and the data behind it, and patterns in the fossil record, with models you can move, a data lab and lots of practice. Everything on this page is free.
Evolution: Variation, Natural Selection by the Numbers and the Fossil Record
Measure the variation in a population and find its mean and range. Run a natural selection model generation by generation and watch the mean draw itself on a graph. Calculate means, judge which explanation the numbers really support, and test the same trait in two environments. Read rock layers for fossils that appear, change and disappear, follow the horse family and the fossil relatives of whales, and practice with questions that never run out.
Start here
What you are learning
S7L5. Obtain, evaluate, and communicate information from multiple sources to explain the theory of evolution of living organisms through inherited characteristics. a. Use mathematical representations to evaluate explanations of how natural selection leads to changes in specific traits of populations over successive generations. Clarification: referencing data should be obtained from multiple sources including, but not limited to, existing research and simulations. Students should be able to calculate means, represent this data in a table or graph, and reference it when explaining the principles of natural selection.b. Construct an explanation based on evidence that describes how genetic variation and environmental factors influence the probability of survival and reproduction of a species. c. Analyze and interpret data for patterns in the fossil record that document the existence, diversity, and extinction of organisms and their relationships to modern organisms. Clarification: evidence of evolution found in comparisons of current/modern organisms such as homologous structures, DNA, and fetal development will be addressed in high school.
Learning targets
Explain how natural selection changes a trait in a population over generations
Use means, tables and graphs as evidence when I explain natural selection
Explain how variation and the environment change the chance of surviving and reproducing
Read the fossil record for organisms that appeared, changed and went extinct
Success criteria
I will be successful when I can:
find the mean and the range of a set of measurements and show my work
put data from several generations in a table and a line graph, and describe the trend
name the four steps of natural selection: variation, overproduction, selection and inheritance
choose the explanation the data support, and reject "they needed to" and "each one changed" explanations
explain why a trait that helps in one environment may not help in another
use "deeper is older" to put rock layers and their fossils in order
describe when kinds of organisms first appear and disappear, and how the number of kinds changes
connect fossil horses and fossil whale relatives to the horses and whales alive today
1Variation comes first
Members of a population differ, and many differences are inherited.
2The environment sorts
Individuals whose traits fit survive and reproduce more often.
3Populations change
Individuals do not evolve. The population changes over generations.
4Numbers are evidence
A mean that moves generation after generation shows the change.
5Rocks keep the record
Fossils show kinds that appeared, changed and went extinct.
Evolution is the change in the inherited traits of a population over many generations. Evolution by natural selection is a scientific theory: a well-tested explanation supported by a great deal of evidence. In science, a theory is not a guess. Some of that evidence comes from living populations that scientists count and measure. More comes from fossils in rock. On this page you will use both.
Part 1 · S7L5.b · Variation
No two are exactly alike
A population is all the members of one species living in one place. Its members are not all the same. The differences in a trait among them are called variation. Much of it is inherited: passed from parents to offspring through genes. Each offspring gets a new mix of genes from its two parents. Now and then a gene changes when it is copied. That change is called a mutation, and it can add new variation. Pick a population, measure 20 members, and find the mean (the average) and the range (largest minus smallest).
Model data: these measurements are made up by the computer each time, but they spread out the way real measurements of a trait do. Tap or click any dot to read one member's measurement.
Read this sample (it never runs out)
Use the dot plot aboveFresh question every time
What makes a trait an adaptation?
An adaptation is an inherited trait that helps an organism survive and reproduce in its environment. The environment is everything around an organism: weather, food, predators and the ground. All three parts must be true. A scar is not inherited, so it is not an adaptation. A thick white coat helps an arctic fox in snow, but the same coat would not help in a hot desert.
Inherited?
Passed from parents through genes. An injury or a learned trick is not.
Helps survival or reproduction?
It gives a better chance to live and have offspring.
In this environment?
A trait helps only where it fits. The environment decides.
Adaptation or not?Fresh question every time
Ask a question. If every beetle in a population were exactly the same shade, could birds change the population's color over many generations?
No. Natural selection can only sort the variation that is already there. If every beetle had the same shade, birds would catch beetles by luck, not by color, and the next generation would still be that same shade. Variation has to come first.
Part 2 · S7L5.a · S7L5.b · Natural selection
Run natural selection, one generation at a time
Charles Darwin and Alfred Russel Wallace each worked out the idea of natural selection on their own. Their idea was first shared with other scientists in 1858, and Darwin explained it in a book in 1859. In natural selection, individuals whose traits fit the environment survive and reproduce more often, so those traits become more common over generations. Here, 20 beetles of different shades live on the ground. Each shade has a number from 1 (lightest) to 9 (darkest). Birds hunt by sight. Press Birds hunt, see who was caught, then press Survivors reproduce. Change the ground at any time.
The ground:
Mean shade of the beetles, by generation
Generation
This is a simplified model. Every generation the birds catch 8 of the 20 beetles. For the first four generations on a ground, chance decides each catch, but a beetle that stands out is far more likely to be caught. After that, to keep the run short, the birds always catch the 8 beetles that stand out most. The 12 survivors have 20 offspring, so more young hatch than the ground can support. Most young have their parent's shade. Some are one or two steps lighter or darker, and a long run gets more of these. Each mean is rounded to one decimal place. Real populations are bigger and change more slowly, but they follow the same steps.
1 · Variation
The beetles already differ in shade, and shade is inherited.
2 · Overproduction
More young hatch than the ground can support, so not all survive.
3 · Selection
Beetles that blend in are caught less often, so more of them survive and reproduce.
4 · Inheritance
Survivors pass their shade to their young. The next generation has more of the helpful shade.
The four steps (it never runs out)
Variation, overproduction, selection or inheritance?Fresh question every time
Ask a question. Did any single beetle in the model get darker during its life?
No. Each beetle kept the shade it hatched with. What changed was the population: dark beetles survived and reproduced more often, so each new generation had more dark beetles and a higher mean shade. Individuals do not evolve; populations change over generations.
Part 3 · S7L5.a · Natural selection by the numbers
Calculate the means, then judge the explanation
Scientists do not measure every member of a population. They measure a sample and find the mean: add all the values, then divide by how many values there are. Comparing the mean of one generation with the mean of a later generation shows whether the trait is changing. Fill in the totals and the means, and the graph will draw each mean you get right.
Add all the values to get the total
Count how many values there are
Divide: total ÷ how many = mean
Compare the means of the two generations
Generation
Model data: the measurements are made up, but the pattern follows real studies. Means here are whole numbers or have one decimal place.
Which explanation do the numbers support? (it never runs out)
Data can show that a population changed. You still need an explanation that fits. A good explanation says some individuals already had the helpful trait, they survived and reproduced more, and so the trait became more common. Reject explanations that say living things changed because they "needed" or "wanted" to, or that each individual changed during its life.
Evaluate the explanationFresh question every time
Ask a question. Why do scientists compare means instead of the measurement of one animal?
One animal can be unusual, and natural selection is about the whole population. The mean uses every measured member, so a change in the mean from one generation to the next shows the population shifting. One animal's measurement cannot show that.
Part 4 · S7L5.b · Survival chances
Same trait, different environment
Probability is the chance that something happens. A trait that fits the environment gives a higher probability of surviving and reproducing. That is a pattern across a whole population, not a promise for one individual. Pick a population and an environment, predict which form does better, then run 50 of each form through one season.
Environment:
This is a simplified model. Each form has a set chance of surviving to reproduce in each environment, and the computer draws every individual's result by chance. Your counts change from run to run, as real counts do. To keep the pattern easy to see, the model only shows runs that land within a few of the expected count. Real counts can vary more.
Two real populations that changed
Peppered moths in England
Clean bark. Tree trunks were pale with lichens. Light moths blended in. A dark form existed but was rare; it was first recorded in 1848.
Sooty bark. Coal soot from factories darkened the trunks. Birds caught more light moths. By 1895, about 98 of every 100 moths near one industrial city were dark.
Clean again. After clean-air laws in the middle of the 1900s, the bark turned pale again. Light moths became common again, and the dark form became rare.
Medium ground finches on Daphne Major
Daphne Major is a small island in the Galápagos. Scientists measured the beaks of the finches there year after year. In 1977 a drought left mostly large, hard seeds. Finches with deeper beaks could crack them, so more of those finches survived and reproduced. In the next generation, the mean beak depth was about half a millimeter deeper. No bird's beak grew: the population changed.
When nothing fits
Sometimes the environment changes too much or too fast. If no members of a population have traits that fit the new conditions, fewer survive and reproduce every generation. If the last members of a species are gone from everywhere on Earth, the species is extinct. A population with a lot of variation has a better chance that some members fit a new environment.
Survival chances practice (it never runs out)
Variation, environment and probabilityFresh question every time
Ask a question. A dark mouse on light sand survived the whole year. Does that prove dark fur helps on light sand?
No. Probability is about the whole population. A dark mouse on light sand has a lower chance of surviving, not zero chance, so some dark mice still make it. To see which fur color helps, compare the share of light mice and the share of dark mice that survive, using many mice.
Part 5 · S7L5.c · The fossil record
Read the rock layers
A fossil is the preserved remains or trace of a living thing from long ago: a bone, a shell, a leaf print, a footprint. Fossils form mostly in sedimentary rock, which builds up in layers of mud and sand. In layers that have not been flipped or disturbed, lower layers are older, because each layer formed on top of the one below it. All the fossils ever found make up the fossil record. Tap a layer to see its fossils.
Youngest (top)
Oldest (bottom)
Number of kinds of fossils found in each layer
Layer (1 = oldest, 6 = youngest)
A simplified model column. The groups are real and appear in the same order they appear in the real fossil record, but no single place on Earth holds exactly these layers, and real columns hold many more kinds. The layers are not drawn to scale. "Dinosaurs" here means the dinosaurs other than birds. "Ammonites" here includes their older coiled-shell relatives.
Existence
Fossils show that many kinds of organisms lived long ago.
Diversity
The number of kinds changes from layer to layer. Over time it has grown, with sudden drops.
Extinction
Kinds that stop appearing and are not alive today are extinct. When many stop at the same level, it was a mass extinction.
The record is incomplete. Most organisms never become fossils. Soft bodies usually decay. A fossil usually forms only when remains are buried quickly. Hard parts such as shells, bones and teeth last best. So a kind missing from one layer may still have been alive then; it just left no fossil there that anyone has found.
Read this column (it never runs out)
Use the column, table and graph aboveFresh question every time
A new column every time (it never runs out)
These columns hold made-up kinds of fossils, labeled A to E, so you have to read the data instead of remembering it.
Made-up kinds in a model columnFresh question every time
Ask a question. Trilobites are found in layers 1, 2 and 3, and in no layer above. Could trilobites have lived a little after layer 3 formed?
Yes, possibly. The fossil record is incomplete, so the last trilobite fossil anyone finds may be a little older than the last trilobite that lived. What the record does show clearly is that trilobites are not found in any younger layer and none are alive today, so they are extinct.
Part 6 · S7L5.c · Fossils and modern organisms
Fossil relatives of horses and whales
Fossils can connect organisms of the past to organisms alive today. Sometimes the fossils from older to younger layers look more and more like a group alive today. That pattern is evidence that the living group is related to those fossil organisms. Put four fossil horses in order from oldest to youngest. Tap a card to give it the next number; tap it again to take the number back.
The horse family is a branching bush, not one straight line. Many branches lived at the same time, and most of them went extinct. Only one branch is alive today: horses, zebras and donkeys.
The fossil relatives of whales
Whales live their whole lives in water and breathe air through a blowhole on top of the head. Fossils of their relatives, found in rocks about 50 to 40 million years old, show animals with legs. Step through them from oldest to youngest and watch three traits: the legs, where the animal lived, and where its nostrils were.
Drawings are simple models, not to scale. These fossil animals are relatives found near the path to modern whales; scientists do not claim that each one is the direct parent species of the next.
Fossil relatives practice (it never runs out)
Horses, whales and living relativesFresh question every time
Part 7 · S7L5.a · S7L5.b · Analyze data
Data lab: finches through drought and rain
A team measured the beak depth of 5 birds in each of six generations of a model finch population. Dry years leave mostly large, hard seeds. Wet years bring plenty of small, soft seeds. Calculate the mean for each generation. Each mean you get right is plotted on the graph. Then read your table and graph to explain what happened.
Mean beak depth (mm), by generation
Generation
Model data: made up, but it follows the real pattern seen in island finches. In real studies scientists measure many more birds.
Read the study (it never runs out)
Use the table and graph aboveFresh question every time
Build an argument (Claim · Evidence · Reasoning)
Pick a question. Choose the best claim, the two pieces of evidence that support it, and the reasoning that connects them.
1 · Claim
2 · Evidence (pick two)
3 · Reasoning
Part 8
Worked examples, step by step
Make your own guess for each step before you reveal it.
Part 9
Evolution in real life
Decide which idea explains each one before you check.
Part 10
Myth or fact?
The most common mix-ups about natural selection and fossils. Decide, then see the truth.
Part 11 · S7L5.a · S7L5.b · S7L5.c
Evolution practice (it never runs out)
Every question is made fresh, with new numbers and new columns. Pick a skill or leave it on Mixed.
Skill: Fresh question every time
Ten questions on the whole unit
Ten questions at a time from every part of S7L5. Press New set any time for different questions.
Sort it: a sound explanation or a mix-up?
Decide whether each statement matches how natural selection works, or makes the "they needed to" or "each one changed" mistake.