Tobin logoTobinEconomics
WebQuest · Unit 12 · SSEPF1d · SSEPF7

Cars, Homes, and Insurance WebQuest

What Does It Really Cost, and Who Carries the Risk?

Work through the stops in order. Each button opens in a new tab: finish that stop, answer on your WebQuest sheet, then come back to this page for the next one.

Start with Stop 1 ↓For teachers ↓
Students

How it works

1. Get your sheet

Your teacher gives you the WebQuest sheet (paper or digital). Every answer goes on it.

2. Open each stop in order

Each stop opens in a new tab. Move the sliders and press the buttons: your answers come from what you see.

3. Come back here

Close the tab, tick Done, and open the next stop. Finished early? Try the bonus.

The WebQuest

Stops

The big question: How do you decide what to buy, what to rent, and which risks to pay someone else to carry?

Stop 1 · about 10 min · your sheet: page 2, questions 1–4

Start Here and the Out-the-Door Price

Read what you are learning, then price Maya’s made-up used car out the door: Georgia’s title tax, the fees, the down payment and the amount she borrows.

Stop 2 · about 15 min · your sheet: page 3, questions 5–8

The Loan Term: 36, 60 or 84 Months

Keep Maya’s made-up loan the same and change only its length, then test the dealer’s “I can get your payment down” offer.

Stop 3 · about 15 min · your sheet: page 4, questions 9–12

Negative Equity and Five Years of Owning It

Compare what is owed with what the car is worth for Maya and for a made-up buyer who puts no money down, then add up five years of owning Maya’s car.

Stop 4 · about 15 min · your sheet: page 5, questions 13–16

Rent or Buy at 25: What Each Costs

Read Maya’s made-up choice at 25 and the real mortgage rate, then compare what owning and renting cost each month and at the start, and a 15-year loan with a 30-year loan.

Stop 5 · about 15 min · your sheet: page 6, questions 17–21

Rent or Buy: Change the Assumptions

Move the sliders in the rent-or-buy model: how long she stays, what home prices and rents do. Watch the answer change, then read both sides.

Stop 6 · about 10 min · your sheet: page 7, questions 22–25

The Risk Pool

See how a premium is built from a big, rare loss, then roll ten years of dice for 30 made-up players and compare the insured with the uninsured.

Wrap-up · your sheet: page 8, question 28

Wrap-up: What it really costs, and who carries the risk

Answer the unit’s big question on your sheet, using what you found today.

Bonus · when you have finished every stop

Bonus: Never underwater

Finished every stop? Help a made-up buyer. Press No money down, 84 months at 12.99%. Raise Down payment ($) a little at a time. What is the smallest down payment (to the nearest $100) that makes Negative equity read Never? Then try a shorter Loan term instead.

Teachers

For teachers

Post this link for your students

A WebQuest through every Part of the free Cars, Homes, and Insurance page (tobinscience.com/econ/housing.html): the car total-cost calculator (out-the-door price with Georgia’s TAVT, the loan term, negative equity, five years of ownership), the rent-or-buy model with sliders, the classroom risk pool and the deductible chooser.

Standards: SSEPF1d, SSEPF7a–c · SSIPS3. SSEPF1d: a decision model for buying a car (Stops 1–3) and for renting vs. buying a home and choosing a mortgage (Stops 4–5). SSEPF7a: why people buy insurance, through a risk pool (Stop 6). SSEPF7b–c: premiums and deductibles on a SAMPLE auto quote (Stop 7).

Time: about 90 minutes (two 45-minute periods, or one block)

What students need

  • One Chromebook, laptop or phone per student
  • No student accounts or sign-ins; nothing to install
  • The printed or digital WebQuest sheet

Every stop at a glance

  • Stop 1: Start + out-the-door price (about 10 min) · Start here · Part 1: Buy a car
  • Stop 2: Loan term (about 15 min) · Part 1: Buy a car
  • Stop 3: Negative equity + cost of ownership (about 15 min) · Part 1: Buy a car · Five years of owning it
  • Stop 4: Rent or buy: the costs (about 15 min) · Parts 2–3: Rent or buy
  • Stop 5: Rent or buy: the assumptions (about 15 min) · Parts 2–3: Rent or buy
  • Stop 6: The risk pool (about 10 min) · Part 4: The risk pool
  • Stop 7: Pick a deductible + practice (about 10 min) · Parts 5–6: Pick a deductible · Part 8: Practice
  • Bonus: Never underwater

Good to know

  • Short on time? Stops 1–4 make a good first day; Stops 5–7 and the Wrap-up a second day.
  • Real numbers are snapshots with sources, read Nov. 6, 2026: Georgia’s 7% TAVT, the $18 title fee and $20 tag fee (Georgia Department of Revenue), and the Freddie Mac average rates, 7.18% (30-year) and 6.57% (15-year), week of Nov. 5, 2026.
  • Maya Brooks, Fall Line Motors, Brown Thrasher Insurance Company, Sweetgum Community Credit Union, the townhouse, the apartment and the risk pool are made up (SAMPLE) and match the notes and the deck. Every growth rate (car value −12%, home value, rent, 4% savings) is hypothetical.
  • Rent vs. buy: the page gives both sides at equal length and no verdict. Score the reasons and the numbers, never the choice. The risk-pool dice are random, so Stop 6’s uninsured savings vary.