Tobin logoTobinEconomics
Unit 12 · SSEPF1d · SSEPF7

Cars, Homes, and Insurance

Buying a car, renting or buying a home, mortgages, and how insurance protects against loss.

Cars, homes and insurance: the car total-cost calculator, rent vs. buy, the risk pool & pick a deductible ↓
1 · Scarcity and Decisions2 · Economic Systems and Growth3 · Markets and Business4 · Measuring the Economy5 · Money, the Fed, and Fiscal Policy6 · Trade and Georgia in the World Economy7 · Life After High School and Careers8 · Paychecks, Taxes, and Budgets9 · Banking and Paying10 · Saving and Investing11 · Credit and Loans12 · Cars, Homes, and Insurance13 · Consumer Rights and Identity Theft
Cars, Homes, and Insurance · SSEPF1d · SSEPF7a–d

Big Purchases and the Risks Behind Them

Price a used car out the door and follow five years of owning it, test renting against buying a home under different assumptions, roll the dice in a risk pool, and find the deductible that costs the least for how often you expect a claim.

Start here

What you are learning

SSEPF1. Analyze major life decisions using economics-based decision-making skills.
d. Apply a rational decision-making model to evaluate other major life choices like employment opportunities, renting a home vs. buying, selecting a mortgage, and buying a car.
SSEPF7. Analyze how insurance and other risk-management strategies protect against financial loss.
a. Explain why people buy insurance.
b. Describe various types of insurance such as automobile, health, life (whole and term), disability, renters, flood and property.
c. Explain the costs and benefits associated with different types of insurance, including deductibles, premiums, coverage limits shared liability, and asset protection.
d. Define insurability and explain why insurance rates can vary.

Learning target

I am learning to weigh the whole cost of a car or a home and to explain how insurance protects against a loss I could not pay for myself.

Success criteria

I will be successful when I can:

  • figure a car’s out-the-door price and its total cost of ownership
  • explain how a longer loan lowers the payment, raises the interest and can leave a buyer owing more than the car is worth
  • compare renting and buying a home and explain how the answer changes with the model’s assumptions
  • explain how a risk pool turns a big, rare loss into a small, certain premium
  • choose a deductible by weighing the premium against what a claim would cost
1dOut the door

The price is only the start: tax, fees, interest, insurance, gas.

1dRent or buy

The answer depends on how long you stay and what prices do.

7aPool the risk

Many small premiums pay for the few big losses.

7cDeductible

A higher deductible lowers the premium but costs more in a claim.

The big question: how do you decide what to buy, what to rent, and which risks to pay someone else to carry? Nothing on this page is advice, and no real dealer, lender, insurer, car brand or policy is named as a choice. Maya Brooks, who appears on this page, is a made-up young HVAC technician. Fall Line Motors (a car dealer), Brown Thrasher Insurance Company and Sweetgum Community Credit Union are made up, and their documents are stamped SAMPLE. Rates marked hypothetical are practice numbers, not predictions. Every real number shows its source and date; it is a snapshot, not a live feed. Nothing you type is sent anywhere or saved.

Part 1 · SSEPF1d · buying a car

The car total-cost calculator

A car costs more than its price. The out-the-door price adds Georgia’s title ad valorem tax (TAVT) and fees. A down payment lowers the amount you borrow. The loan’s length changes the payment and the interest, and every car loses value as it ages (depreciation). Start with Maya’s made-up car, then change any number.

What is owed vs. what the car is worth

The loan balance falls with each payment; the car’s value falls too (a hypothetical 12% a year). Where the balance line is above the value line, the buyer has negative equity: selling the car would not pay off the loan.

The car’s valueStill owed on the loanNegative equity (owes more than it is worth)

The same loan, five lengths

Five years of owning it: the total cost of ownership

Everything she pays in the first five years, minus what the car is worth when she sells it then. The running costs start at Maya’s made-up budget lines; change them to match another driver.

Think: the dealer says, “I can get your payment down.” What does a longer loan really do?

Parts 2–3 · SSEPF1d · renting or buying a home

Rent or buy at 25: a model with sliders

Buying minus renting: her net worth if she sells after each year

Buying came out aheadRenting came out ahead

Fifteen years or thirty

The same loan at the two average rates. A 15-year loan has a higher payment but a lower rate and far less interest.

Two sides, the same model

Think: slide Years she stays to 1. Why does buying lose money if she sells after one year?

Part 4 · SSEPF7a · why people buy insurance

The risk pool: 30 players, two dice, ten years

Each player’s risk
The insured players’ deductible

Insured (15 players)
Not insured (15 players)
Think: after ten years, which group has more players with savings left? Which group lost a little every year?

Parts 5–6 · SSEPF7b–c · premiums and deductibles

Pick a deductible

The premium is the price of the policy. The deductible is the part of each covered loss you pay before the insurer pays. A higher deductible means a lower premium, because the insurer pays less of each claim. Which costs less depends on how often you have a claim.

The average cost a year for each deductible:

The yearly premium+ chance × deductible

Where two deductibles cost the same

Think: the $1,000 deductible has the lowest average cost at a 10% chance. Why might Maya still keep $500 while her savings are small?

Part 7

Myth or fact?

Common claims about cars, homes and insurance. Decide, then see the truth.

Part 8

Practice: cars, homes, and insurance

Ten questions at a time on buying a car, renting or buying a home, mortgages and insurance. Press New set any time for different questions.

Part 9

Vocabulary

The unit’s 24 words, colored by the part of the unit where they first appear.

← Unit 11Credit and Loans