Tobin logoTobinEconomics
Unit 1 · SSEF1 · SSEF2

Scarcity and Decisions

Scarcity, the factors of production, opportunity cost, thinking at the margin and incentives.

Scarcity and decisions: who gets it, opportunity cost, the margin & incentives ↓
1 · Scarcity and Decisions2 · Economic Systems and Growth3 · Markets and Business4 · Measuring the Economy5 · Money, the Fed, and Fiscal Policy6 · Trade and Georgia in the World Economy7 · Life After High School and Careers8 · Paychecks, Taxes, and Budgets9 · Banking and Paying10 · Saving and Investing11 · Credit and Loans12 · Cars, Homes, and Insurance13 · Consumer Rights and Identity Theft
Scarcity and Decisions · SSEF1–2

Scarcity, Choices, Opportunity Cost and Thinking at the Margin

Sort scarcity from shortages and the factors of production, match the nine ways to decide who gets a scarce thing, build a decision-making grid that names your opportunity cost, run the food truck at the margin, predict how people respond to incentives, and review the whole unit.

Start here

What you are learning

SSEF1. Analyze how scarcity affects the choices of individuals, businesses, and governments.
a. Explain that scarcity is a basic, permanent condition that exists because unlimited wants exceed limited productive resources.
b. Compare and contrast strategies for allocating scarce resources such as by price, majority rule, contests, force, sharing, lottery, authority, first-come-first-served, and personal characteristics.
c. Define and give examples of productive resources (i.e. factors of production): natural resources (i.e. land), human resources (i.e. labor and human capital), physical capital and entrepreneurship.
d. Apply the concept of opportunity cost (the forgone next best alternative) to personal choices, as well as business and government decisions.
SSEF2. Give examples of how rational decision-making entails comparing the marginal benefits and the marginal costs of an action.
a. Explain that rational decisions occur when the marginal benefits of an action equal or exceed the marginal costs.
b. Explain that individuals, businesses, and governments respond to positive and negative incentives in predictable ways.

Learning target

I am learning to explain why scarcity forces every person, business and government to choose, and how to make and judge those choices.

Success criteria

I will be successful when I can:

  • explain why scarcity is permanent and how it differs from a shortage
  • sort examples into the four factors of production
  • compare the nine ways to allocate a scarce thing, with a strength and a weakness for each
  • use a decision-making grid to name the opportunity cost of a choice
  • apply the rule that a rational decision does one more when marginal benefit is equal to or greater than marginal cost
  • predict how people respond to positive and negative incentives
1aScarcity

Unlimited wants, limited resources. It never goes away.

1cFactors

Land, labor, physical capital and entrepreneurship make everything.

1bWho gets it?

Nine ways to decide. Each one picks different winners.

1dOpportunity cost

The next best alternative you give up when you choose.

2aThe margin

Do one more when its benefit is equal to or greater than its cost.

2bIncentives

Rewards and penalties get predictable responses.

The big question: imagine 50,000 people want a ticket to a show and there are 5,000 seats. However the tickets get handed out, most of those people go home without one. Who should get them, and who decides? Keep it in mind as you work through the page.

Part 1 · SSEF1a

Scarcity: unlimited wants, limited resources

People want goods (things you can touch, like shoes or a phone) and services (work done for you, like a haircut). When one want is met, another takes its place: wants are unlimited. The productive resources that make goods and services are limited. That gap is scarcity, and it is basic and permanent: a billionaire still has only 24 hours in a day.

An individualMoney and timeWork a Saturday shift or study for a test.
A businessWorkers, space, moneyHire one more cook or buy a second oven.
A governmentTax dollarsRepave roads or build a new fire station.

Scarcity or a shortage?

A shortage is short-term: buyers want more than is available at the current price, and it can end when more is made or the price changes. Scarcity never ends. Decide for each one, then check your sort.

Part 2 · SSEF1c

The factors of production

Everything that is produced, from a peach to a phone, uses the same four kinds of productive resources. Click a factor to see it at work in a food truck (a fictional business you will meet again in Part 5).

Sort it: which factor?

Choose the factor for each item. Careful: one choice is Not a factor. In economics, money is not capital; money buys capital.

Part 3 · SSEF1b

Who gets it? Nine ways to allocate a scarce thing

There is never enough for everyone, so every society needs a rule for who gets scarce goods, services and resources. That is allocation. Economists list nine common methods. Each is a different solution to the same problem, and each picks different winners. Click a method.

Comparing methods. Economists ask three questions: Is it fair, and fair by whose definition? Is it efficient: does the good go to the people who value it most, without wasted time or effort? Does it give people an incentive to produce more of what is scarce? No method wins on every question, and which one is fairest is a question of values, so this page never scores it.

Name the method

Read each situation and choose the allocation method it uses.

Try a method on one problem

A school has 40 parking spaces and 120 seniors who drive. Pick any method and see who wins, who loses, and what each side could say. There is no right answer here.

Part 4 · SSEF1d

Opportunity cost: the decision-making grid

Every choice is a trade-off. The opportunity cost of a choice is the value of the next best alternative you give up: not everything you could have done, only the single best option you did not choose. A decision-making grid lists the alternatives down the side and the criteria (what matters) across the top. Mark each box + or −, choose, and the grid names your opportunity cost.

Click a box to switch it: blank → + → − → blank. Click ★ on a criterion that matters most to you: its + counts twice.

Governments face it too. Georgia’s lottery money pays for both HOPE scholarships and Pre-K, so a dollar spent on one is a dollar the other does not get. In February 1942 the United States stopped making new cars for civilians so auto factories could build for the war: new family cars were the opportunity cost.

Part 5 · SSEF2a

Thinking at the margin: the food truck

Marginal means one more. A food truck at a Saturday festival decides how many hours to stay open. Each hour costs the same $50 (two workers at $15 and $20 of generator fuel): the marginal cost. As the crowd thins, each hour brings in less: the marginal benefit. The rule: open one more hour when its marginal benefit is equal to or greater than its marginal cost. Move the slider.

The food truck is a fictional classroom model with made-up round numbers.

Marginal cost of each hour
The crowd
Past costs do not count. The truck already paid a non-refundable fee for its festival spot. Should that fee change how many hours it stays open?
Part 6 · SSEF2a

Margin practice (it never runs out)

Every question is made fresh from the food-truck model, so you can practice as long as you want. Pick a skill, or leave it on Mixed. The table shows the numbers for each question.

Part 7 · SSEF2b

Incentives: predict the response

An incentive pushes people to act a certain way. A positive incentive is a reward that gets people to do more of something. A negative incentive is a penalty or cost that gets people to do less. An incentive works by changing the marginal benefit or the marginal cost of a choice. Pick a card, decide what kind of incentive it is, and predict the response.

Part 8

Myth or fact?

The most common mix-ups about scarcity, cost and choices. Decide, then see the truth.

Part 9

Practice: the whole unit

Ten questions at a time from every part of SSEF1 and SSEF2: scarcity, the factors of production, allocation, opportunity cost, the margin and incentives. Press New set any time for different questions.

Part 10

Vocabulary